How to Get More Dental Patients: A 7-Step Plan
Learn how to get more dental patients in seven steps, from answering missed calls to local SEO, reviews, ads, and tracking real patient value.

By Michael Anderson, Co-Founder at Wonderist Agency
Before you pay to get more patients, count the ones you already paid to reach.
Say your practice gets 100 new patient calls this month. Based on one study of 4,280 calls at 26 practices, about 38 of those calls would go unanswered. (1)
That’s 38 people who called and got nobody. Maybe it was a mom calling on her lunch break about her son’s chipped tooth. Maybe it was someone new to town, finally ready to book the cleaning they’ve put off for two years. If only 1 in 4 of them would have booked, that’s about 9 or 10 new patients. At a baseline value of $4,000 each (Wonderist patient value model), roughly $38,000 in lifetime value, every month. (5)
The patients you already paid to reach
What 100 new patient calls a month can look like
100
new patient calls this month
38
calls go unanswered
9 to 10
would have booked, if 1 in 4 did
$38K
in lifetime value, every month
No new ad spend
These are patients you already reached. They just didn’t reach you.
Sources: Peerlogic, 4,280 calls across 26 practices (February 2026); Wonderist patient value model ($4,000 baseline). The 1 in 4 booking rate is an illustration.
You don’t need new ad spend or a new campaign for this. These are patients you already reached.
And this isn’t about a front desk that doesn’t care. Lunch coverage, a line of patients checking out, a hygienist running behind: calls slip through at busy practices every day. The point is that you can see it, and fix it.
How to Get New Dental Patients: A Seven-Step Plan
1. Answer the phone, and see your calls
Running ads while the phones go unanswered is like whitening teeth before treating the cavity. It looks better for a day.
First, find out what’s really happening on your calls. Who called? Was it a new patient? Did anyone pick up? Did the call end in an appointment? Our Call Insights Dashboard in The Wonderful CRM answers those questions for you, without spreadsheets or manual tracking.
Then fix what it shows. Start with the times calls are most likely to slip: lunch hours, after 5 p.m., and Mondays.
2. Win the review race
Patients read before they book. Across healthcare, 84% of patients say they check online reviews before choosing a new provider, and 51% say they read at least six. (2)
Patients read before they book
U.S. patients across healthcare
check online reviews before choosing a new provider
read at least six reviews
Source: rater8, How Patients Choose Their Doctors (2025). Covers patients across healthcare, not dental only.
Ask every happy patient for a review before they leave the chair. Reply to every review, good or bad. A calm, kind reply to a bad review is read by every future patient who sees it.
The reviews that help most are specific. “They got me in the same day and explained everything” tells a nervous patient more than five stars ever could.
3. Get found where patients look
“Dentist near me” is a giant. It gets 1,000,000 searches a month in the U.S. and scores a keyword difficulty (KD) of 76, which is very hard. (3) KD is a 0 to 100 score that SEO research tools use for how hard it is to reach page one.
Procedure searches are a different story. “Cosmetic dentist near me” gets 60,500 searches a month. “Dental implants near me” gets 135,000. Both are rated very easy to rank for. (3)
So don’t fight for the general search first. Win the procedures you want more of, inside the map pack. That’s the map and short list of three local practices at the top of Google. Fill out your Google Business Profile completely, list every service, add fresh photos monthly, and build a page for each procedure.
Where you rank depends on where the patient is standing
A local ranking grid checks “cosmetic dentist near me” from dozens of points around your office
cosmetic dentist near me
Your Practice
Dental practice
Dental practice
Illustration, not real ranking data
Our Local SEO for Dentists playbook walks through the full setup. Once the foundation is in place, our Local SEO Boost program can build on it.
4. Let your website and photos close the deal
Reviews and your map listing start the decision. Your website finishes it.
Dr. Joseph Blalock of Lakeside Dental in Lenoir City, TN, told us he’s seeing 100 new patients a month, and that patients walk in saying, “Wow, you have a really good website.” (6)
What does a website need to turn a visit into an appointment? Real photos of your real team, not stock. A separate page for each service that explains it in plain English and gives a price range where you can. And a “Book Now” button patients can see on their phone the moment the page loads.
Think about the patient comparing three practices at 10 p.m. One site shows a smiling stock model. Yours shows the actual hygienist they’ll meet on Tuesday. That’s usually the one they call.
If your site is missing any of these, our Websites and Photo & Video teams can build them for you.
5. Spend ad dollars on the procedures that pay
Google Ads work best when each campaign points at one procedure, not at the word “dentist.”
Our Google Ads packages are sized to fit your practice’s budget, so you can start focused and grow from there.
Here’s what a focused campaign looks like. In 2023, Amaya Dental, a general practice in Miami, ran a “$500 Off Invisalign & Free Whitening” campaign. It produced 632 leads on $10,895 of spend, or $17.24 a lead. (4)
A cost per lead only means something once you know how many of those leads became patients. Which brings us to the next step.
6. Track patients, not leads
Most reports stop at the lead. Ours go to collected revenue.
Think of it like case acceptance. You wouldn’t call a treatment plan a success because the patient nodded along at the consult. You’d look at who actually scheduled.
Our PMS Integration connects your practice management system (Dentrix, Eaglesoft, Open Dental, or NexHealth) to your marketing. Setup takes about 8 to 10 days. After that, you can see which campaign brought in which patient, and what that patient was worth.
Not every patient is worth the same. A baseline general patient is worth about $4,000 over eight years. An engaged patient who adds whitening or aligners is worth about $7,000. A cosmetic or implant patient is worth $18,000 to $33,000 (Wonderist Agency, 2026).
Not every new patient is worth the same
Lifetime value by patient type, over about eight years
Baseline
Engaged
Cosmetic or implant
Source: Wonderist, What’s a New Dental Patient Really Worth? (2026). Combined value uses the $25,000 midpoint.
A $150 lead can be a bargain and a $17 lead can be a waste, depending on the patient behind it.
Conversion Rate
$302K
New Patient Production
$314.5K
Sum of Production
Leads by Source
1.12K
Call Insights
7. Keep the patients you have
The cheapest new patient is the one a happy patient sends you.
On average, a happy patient refers 1 to 2 people. We model it at 1.6 referred patients per happy patient. That lifts a baseline patient from $4,000 to $10,400 in combined value. (5)
Marketing gets attention. Experience builds loyalty, and loyalty is what gets your name passed along at the soccer game and the office lunch.
So start with the calls and finish with the referrals. In between, measure every step by the patients it brings in.
The good news? Most of this plan starts with things you already have: a phone, happy patients, a website, and a team that cares. The work is making sure none of it leaks.
At Wonderist, we’ve worked with more than 1,200 dental practices, and one thing has become pretty clear: the practices that grow fastest aren’t always the ones spending the most. They’re the ones that know where every patient came from.
Most agencies will keep sending you lead reports. We’d rather show you the money.
Want to see where your practice is leaking? We’d love to show you. Talk to our team at wonderistagency.com/contact-us.
Notes
- Peerlogic, 4,280 calls across 26 practices, February 2026.
- rater8, How Patients Choose Their Doctors (2025) (1,000+ U.S. patients across healthcare, completed December 2024).
- SEMrush, U.S. database, October 2026.
- Wonderist Google Ads page (the 2023 Amaya Dental campaign).
- What’s a New Dental Patient Really Worth? (Wonderist Agency, 2026).
- Wonderist testimonials (Lakeside Dental).
About the Author

Michael Anderson
Co-Founder, Wonderist Agency
Michael co-founded Wonderist Agency and helped grow it from a two-person venture into a team trusted by more than 1,200 dental brands, with seven straight years on the Inc. 5000. Before Wonderist, he worked in growth and online marketing at a Fortune 500 healthcare incubator, and today he focuses on pairing standout creative with ROI tracking tied to practice management software.
